Allgeier is not flashy, but the Cardinals needed exactly this kind of dependable body in a room hit hard by injuries. He runs with sturdy downhill intent, has never put the ball on the ground as a pro and has been available every week. The 2025 efficiency dip tempers the excitement, yet his reliability is valuable.
Strengths: Excellent durability, trustworthy ball security, compact power and red-zone usefulness. He has topped 500 rushing yards in all four NFL seasons and brings a long active games-played streak.
Weaknesses: His 3.6 yards per carry in 2025 was a step down, and he is not the explosive centerpiece that Arizona drafted Jeremiyah Love to be. He offers more as a physical complement than a high-volume creator.